Unlike some listservs that I regret signing up for, this one is generally pretty quiet. Usually it’s 1-2 posts per week about someone receiving some sort of literary award (although unless i missed it, nobody posted on cynthia ozick winning a couple of PEN lifetime achievement awards last week, despite DFW having raved about her work in past interviews, and also teaching her work, i believe) or someone posting something David Foster Wallace or lit-related. However, sometimes a flurry of activity will ignite and last for a day or so, and these flurries can provide much entertainment. To wit, see the following excerpts of this thread that emerged this weekend:
|
|
| Sent: |
Sat 4/26/08 7:12 PM |
| To: |
wallace-l (wallace-l@waste.org) |
Here’s a gossipy article on n+1 editor Keith Gessen ostensibly about his new book but mostly about how much he hates McSweeney’s.
As a founding editor of n+1, the literary magazine whose vocal fan base belies its twice-yearly 7,500-copy print run, Mr. Gessen and his colleagues have assailed other publications they believe have squandered their eminence (The New Republic) or never merited it (McSweeney’s and anything else associated with the writer Dave Eggers).
http://www.nytimes.com/2008/04/27/fashion/27gessen.html?ex=1366948800
—-
| Sent: |
Sat 4/26/08 8:39 PM |
|
|
|
|
> Here’s a gossipy article on n+1 editor Keith Gessen ostensibly about his > new book but mostly about how much he hates McSweeney’s.
“If you’re going to be a writer, you have to not make a living”, says the guy.
Yeah, right. You should also have twelve toes.
It´s so easy to sound cool saying stuff like “you have to [insert non-literary random characteristic]” in order to be a good writer. And I love most things McSweeney´s does. Are they hated by many people in the US? I don´t get it. I´ve been to 826 Valencia in San Francisco last month, it´s a wonderful place. I met Eggers there. This enthusiasm they bring to publishing (which Keith Gessen despises) is more than welcome. By the way, just finished reading “Arkansas”, by John Brandon, recently published by McSweeney´s. I liked it a lot. A crime novel with an unusual pace and some great characters. And clever dialogue, to the point of being TOO clever here and there. Daniel — Daniel Galera http://ranchocarne.org
——————————-
You can watch him on Titlepage TV with Daniel Menaker (and Sloane Crosley) here: http://www.titlepage.tv/episodes/episode-2-you-always-remember-first-time?page=1
Has anyone read his book? I’m interested. Kunkel’s book was pretty weak, I thought, but it wouldn’t be hard to knock Eggers off his perch–the guy excels mostly in design and philanthropy. Although, I must take a step back and say I have not read What is the What.
On Sat, Apr 26, 2008 at 5:07 PM, Jake wrote:
> Keith who?
> > > On Sat, Apr 26, 2008 at 1:35 PM, Matt wrote:
> > > Seriously sounds pretty douchebaggy. I enjoyed his novel and was pretty close to an N+1 subscription, but I’m hesitating now
> > > > > > On Sat, Apr 26, 2008 at 1:28 PM, Travis wrote
> > > > > This guy kinda sounds like a douche bag.
—————————
I love how this listserv, which has a history of taking Eggers to task and generally getting pretty pissed off that Eggers and McSweeney’s get the commercial attention and critical acclaim that they do, is also quick to weigh in on someone else doing the same and claim it to be douchebaggery. Not that I agree or disagree, I just think the whole thing is funny.
I’m probably one of the few people on the list who actually likes DFW, Vollmann and Eggers, whereas most seem to have a pretty strong dislike for at least one of the three (and I’m gonna go out on a pretty sturdy limb and say that most on the list are way better equipped, whether via literary education or general intelligence, to form and express such opinions than i am). So for me, this is a great, interesting way for me to learn about Keith Gessen and n+1 enough to sound halfway intelligent if/when someone brings him/it up in conversation. It’s also fascinating to see that the literary criticism world is somewhat similar to the music criticism world, with McSweeney’s apparently being a philosophical corollary to Badaboom Gramophone.
Anyone interested in signing up for the list or learning more about DFW should go here:http://www.thehowlingfantods.com/dfw/wallace-l.html